Kya Khuda Ka Inkaar Ilm Hai Ya Sirf Ghuroor?
(Har Atheist Ke Aitrazat Ka Ahle Sunnat Wal Jamaat Ki Qat‘i Daleelon Se Mukammal Radd)
Javed Akhtar aur Mufti shamail nadvi ke Debate ka Radd.
Aaj ke daur me jab shuhurat ko ilm aur taaliyon ko daleel samjha ja raha hai, tab kuch mashhoor log Khuda ke wujood par sawal utha kar khud ko “progressive” zahir karte hain.
Inhi me ek naam Javed Akhtar ka hai, jisne “Does God Exist?” jaise sawal ko naye andaaz me pesh kiya.
Magar yaad rahe —
sawal uthana ilm nahi hota,
jawab bardasht karna ilm hota hai.
Is post ka maqsad Ahle Sunnat wal Jamaat ke us aqeede ko wazeh karna hai jo Qur’an, Sunnat aur sadiyon ke ilm par mabni hai.
------------------------------------------
Sabse Bunyadi Ghalti:
Khuda Ko “Cheez” Samajh Lena
Javed Akhtar (Aethist) ka bunyadi aitraz ye hai:
Sawal: “Jo dikhai nahi deta, use maana kaise jaye?”
Jawab: Yahin se poori soch ghalat ho jaati hai, kyunki:
👉 Khuda koi cheez nahi ke aankh me aaye
👉 Khuda makhlooq nahi ke had me bandhe
Al Quran >Us jaisa koi nahi.
(Surah Ash-Shura: 11)
Hawa, bijli, rooh Aur bhi bahut kuch - aankh se nahi dikhta
lekin unka inkaar koi aaqil nahi karta.
➡️ To phir Allah Ta‘ala ka na dikhna, na hone ki daleel kaise ho sakta hai?
Allah ka Hona khud Dunya ki har cheez sabit karti hai.
ab koi pagal ho jaye to usko kitna hi dalil do wo nahi samjhega.
___________________________________________
Sawal: “Mazhab Khuda par ja kar soch band kar deta hai.”
Jawab: Haqeeqat iska bilkul ulat hai.
📌 Farq yeh hai:
Mazhabi aadmi wahan rukta hai jahan aql ki had khatam hoti hai
Atheist wahan bhi ghusna chahta hai jahan aql ka kaam hi nahi
❗ “Khuda se pehle kaun?” poochna aisa hi hai jaise:
zero se pehle kaunsa number?
North Pole se upar kya?
📌 Alahazrat Imam Ahmed Raza Khan farmate hain:
“Jahan ‘kyun’ ka matlab hi baqi na rahe, wahan sawal ilm nahi, jahalat hota hai.”
Khuda cause ka nateeja nahi,
balki har cause ka sabab hai.
________________________________________
Sawal: “Khuda Time Me Hai, Tabhi To Kehte Hain Hamesha Se Hai”
Jawab: Ye tasawwur bhi ghalat bunyaad par khada hai.
Ahle Sunnat ka aqeeda:
Time khud makhlooq hai
Din, raat, saal — sab paida ki hui cheezen hain
📖 Qur’an (Kanzul Imaan):
“Wahi pehla hai aur wahi aakhri.”
(Surah Al-Hadeed: 3)
“Hamesha se” ka matlab:
ye nahi ke Khuda time ke andar chal raha hai
balki ye ke Khuda time ka khaliq hai
📌 Alahazrat Imam Ahmed Raza Khan Farmate hai:
“Khuda ko zaman me qaid karna, usey makhlooq banana hai.”
----------------------------------------------
Sawal: Agar Khuda Hai To Duniya Me Dukh Kyun?”
Jawab: Ye atheism ka sabse purana sawal hai.
Magar asal sawal ye hona chahiye: ❓ Agar dukh na hota to:
sabr ka kya matlab hota?
insaaf ka kya matlab hota?
Qayamat kyun hoti?
Al Qur’an
“Kya log ye samajhte hain ke sirf keh dene se chhod diye jayenge?”
(Surah Al-Ankaboot: 2)
➡️ Dukh Khuda ke na hone ki daleel nahi
➡️ balki Aakhirat ke hone ki daleel hai
----------------------------------------------
Sawal: Qatl Aur Rape Ho Rahe Hain, Khuda Kyun Nahi Rokta?”
Iska jawab teen qat‘i pehluon me hai:
(1) Ikhtiyar (Free Will)
Agar Khuda har jurm par haath pakad leta:
insaan robot hota
gunah aur sawab ka koi matlab na hota
📖 “Chahe shukar kare chahe na-shukri.”
(Surah Ad-Dahr: 3)
Zulm ka hona Khuda ki razamandi nahi,
balki insaan ke ikhtiyar ka ghalat istemal hai.
(2) Duniya adalat nahi, imtihan hai
Agar har qaatil aur rapist turant pakda jata:
Qayamat be-maani ho jati
Jannat–Jahannam ka tasawwur khatam ho jata
“Allah zulm karne walon se ghafil nahi.”
(Surah Ibrahim: 42)
Der hona chhoot nahi,
mohlat hai.
(3) Ulta sawal
Atheist poochta hai:
“Khuda kyun nahi rokta?”
Hum poochte hain:
“Agar Khuda nahi, to zulm ghalat kyun?”
Atheism me:
zulm sirf chemical reaction hai
rape biological urge hai
➡️ Phir “insaf” aur “gunah” jaise alfaaz be-maani ho jaate hain.
Sawal: “Science Ne Sab Samjha Diya, Khuda Ki Zarurat Nahi”
Science kaise batati hai,
Deen kyun batata hai.
Science:
process batati hai
Deen:
sabab batata hai
📌 Alahazrat Imam Ahmed Raza Khan Farmate hai:
“Aql khud Khuda ki mohtaj hai, aql se Khuda ka inkaar aql ki tauheen hai.”
-------------------------------------------------------
Sawal: “Mazhab Insaan Ne Banaya Hai”
Jawab:
Agar mazhab insaan ne banaya hota:
wo apni khwahish ke khilaaf qanoon kyun banata?
nafs todne wali ibadat kyun hoti?
📖 “Aur ye Qur’an kisi insaan ki banawat nahi.”
(Surah Al-Haqqah: 43)
🧠 Asal Masla Kya Hai?
Masla Khuda ke wujood ka nahi,
masla jawab-dehi se bachne ka hai.
📖 “Unhone inkaar kiya jab ke unke dil yaqeen kar chuke the.”
(Surah An-Naml: 14)
Alahazrat Imam Ahmed Raza Khan Farmate hai:
“Khuda ka inkaar aksar dimaagh ka nahi, nafs ka faisla hota hai.”
-----------------------------------------------------
Nasihat Social media pe Javed Akhtar aur shamail nadvi ka video viral ho raha hai
Aur kuchh log housala Afzayi kar rahe hain.
Yaad rahe Javed Akhtar mulhid hai aur shamail nadvi wahabi Deobandi
Debate ke baad Javed Akhtar ka hanth chuma aur Apne sar pe hanth Rakha shamail nadvi ne.
har mashhoor cheez se mutasir na hon
aqeede ko dalail aur mu‘tabar ilm se parakhain
Aqeedah taaliyon se nahi,
Qur’an, Sunnat aur Ahle Sunnat ke mu‘tabar buzurgon ke maslak se banta hai.
Aur samjhne ke liye padhiye ye Post
